[+] KH argues that because only the Alcor self-elected board at the time knew what to do in the Dora Kent crises, and that a board elected otherwise-- presumably by the Bylaw-Enabled Director Electorate-- that therefore the self-elected board is still the way to work today and in the future. In other words, the idea of the self-elected board proved itself in that crisis. I would argue that a Director-Electorate board would have pre-empted that crisis in the first place-- so that it would not have occurred-- and that that would be the case today and in the future.
Keith asks straightfowardly- what board members should be replaced, pretending that the debate is about that-- that's its personal-- which it is not-- it's about the original alcor bylaw and membership partipication as built into the process by the founding fathers of Alcor, Fred and Linda Chamberlain. Despite that however, I'll name Saul Kent to be replaced-- since he's the one who caused the dicey Dora Kent incident-- and who facilitated the 1994 split-- and who today leads SA Inc into direct comptetition with Alcor for the services of Alcor's own members and therefore represents a conflict of interest with Alcor. But again, that's beside the point-- it's just that KH begged for it. So there's my answer.
Welcome to the Blogger.com site for Alcor Democracy. [More] just below is the latest post-- below that, several of the latest posts by subject line-- and then below that-- the alphabetical index. Finally at the bottom, some useful introductory remarks.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most recent posts
-
▼
2008
(92)
-
▼
February
(58)
- ALCOR UNITED-- 00-- thread on Alcor democracy
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 03-- Alcor mysteries vs. bylaw
- ED SWANK-- ACS-- 00-- suggestions
- ASCHWIN DEWOLF-- 00-- FD refers to in CF
- 501c3 STATUS-- 01-- Merkle invokes potential 501c3...
- EMAIL GROUP-- 00-- I'll form my own email group here.
- KEITH HENSON-- 04-- More history confusing.
- PETITION-- 00-- ReformAlcor guest book hidden
- COLD FILTER-- 02-- Following Monday shows slowdown...
- CONTINUUM-- 00-- My blog tracking before this spec...
- PRIVATE EMAIL GROUP-- 01-- I asked to be deleted f...
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 02-- Back to the real issue pos...
- CRYONET-- Cryonics discussions on Alcor bylaws
- NEW STRATEGY-- 01-- I'll be containing my views
- STEVE BRIDGE-- 00-- Intense research on the matter...
- KEITH HENSON-- 03-- KH defends self-electing proce...
- ALCOR-- volunteer opportunities-- Chapman should a...
- SILENCE-- 03-- CryoNet under-utilized
- SILENCE-- 02-- Readers don't post
- SILENCE-- 01-- Contined silence make internet obso...
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 05-- Alcor's search engine s...
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 03-- Legalities of changing Alc...
- FD-- 01-- Fails to contextualize properly
- LEADERSHIP-- 01-- Dave denies leadership
- KEITH HENSON-- 02-- Incidents have nothing to do w...
- DISAPPEARING CRYONICISTS-- 01-- Cold Filter virtua...
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 01-- blog
- EARLIER NOTES-- Alcor democracy on Philossifur's C...
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 02-- Members may already have r...
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 05-- Mike Darwin claimed responsibilty
- GEORGE-- 00-- takes it too far--
- COLD FILTER-- FD-- 00-- once again, takes the wron...
- ALCOR-- board meetings-- 01-- March meeting promis...
- FRED-- 01-- Waiting to hear more from Fred on this.
- NARRATIVE-- 10-- Silence
- GATEKEEPERS-- Steve Bridge-- 01-- My analysis of h...
- COLD FILTER-- Alcor board of directors discussion-...
- COLD FILTER-- Original Alcor bylaws-- thread by CP...
- COLD FILTER--Let's all work together-- thread by Dave
- COLD FILTER-- Kidnapped-- thread by Dave
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 01-- Dave lists more than just ...
- KEITH HENSON-- 01-- Henson didn't know about origi...
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- Dave Pizer's forum about democr...
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 04-- Alcor articles of incorporation
- GATEKEEPERS-- 02-- Wowk-VanSickle do NOT respond t...
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 04-- New line of reasoning b...
- GATEKEEPERS-- 01-- Keith Henson's view tended to a...
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 03-- CPlatt's original post to CF o...
- COLD FILTER-- 01-- No update Monday.
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 02-- conflicting narrative from FCh...
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 03-- google search
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 01-- change may have been illegal
- ASTONISHING HYPOTHESIS-- 00-- Pizer points to new ...
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 00-- FD points out it was not a fai...
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 02-- FD's approximation method
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 01-- history of this option
- VOTE OF CONFIDENCE-- 01-- Cold filter thread exami...
- WEBSITE-- ReformAlcor.org-- 01-- New site announced.
-
▼
February
(58)
Alphabetical index of keywords -- sub-keywords
- 00-- OVERVIEW-- 00-- Pizer and CPlatt have gone silent (1)
- 01-- WELCOME-- Alcor Democracy Movement (1)
- 501c3 STATUS-- 01-- Merkle invokes potential 501c3 problem (1)
- ALCOR UNITED-- 00-- thread on Alcor democracy (1)
- ALCOR-- article of incorpoation-- director electroate (1)
- ALCOR-- board meetings-- 01-- March meeting promises tension (1)
- ALCOR-- volunteer opportunities-- Chapman should add Bylaw Research (1)
- ASCHWIN DEWOLF-- 00-- FD refers to in CF (1)
- ASTONISHING HYPOTHESIS-- 00-- Pizer points to new ground (1)
- BYLAW APPROVAL?-- 01-- What's this??? Take a look (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 00-- FD points out it was not a fair change (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 01-- change may have been illegal (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 02-- conflicting narrative from FChamberlain and other info (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 03-- CPlatt's original post to CF on discovery of original bylaw (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 04-- Alcor articles of incorporation (1)
- BYLAW CHANGE-- 05-- Mike Darwin claimed responsibilty (1)
- case report (1)
- COLD FILTER-- 01-- No update Monday. (1)
- COLD FILTER-- 02-- Following Monday shows slowdown in posting. (1)
- COLD FILTER-- 03-- Slowdown continues. (1)
- COLD FILTER-- Alcor board of directors discussion-- thread by Steve Bridge (1)
- COLD FILTER-- FD-- 00-- once again (1)
- COLD FILTER-- Kidnapped-- thread by Dave (1)
- COLD FILTER-- Let's all work together-- thread by Dave (1)
- COLD FILTER-- Original Alcor bylaws-- thread by CPlatt (1)
- CONTINUUM-- 00-- My blog tracking before this specialiized blog (1)
- CRYONET-- Cryonics discussions on Alcor bylaws (1)
- CRYONET-- David Pizer messages (1)
- CRYONICS-- Alcor-- democracy-- dictatorship model (1)
- D-- 04-- reports board threw a bone to Pizer-- insufficient (1)
- DAVE PIZER-- 00-- Public disappearance. (1)
- DAVE PIZER-- 01-- Reappears with open ultimatum etter to board (1)
- DEBATE-- invitation-- Alcor board (1)
- democracy (1)
- DICTATORSHIP MODEL-- cream of crop argument (1)
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 01-- history of this option (1)
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 02-- FD's approximation method (1)
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 03-- google search (1)
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 04-- New line of reasoning by ME (1)
- DIRECTOR ELECTORATE-- 05-- Alcor's search engine shows no hits (1)
- DIRECTORS-- Let's clear the air (1)
- DISAPPEARING CRYONICISTS-- 01-- Cold Filter virtually aband (1)
- EARLIER NOTES-- Alcor democracy on Philossifur's Continuum (1)
- ED SWANK-- ACS-- 00-- suggestions (1)
- EMAIL GROUP-- 00-- I'll form my own email group here. (1)
- FD-- 01-- Fails to contextualize properly (1)
- FD-- 02-- Posts observation of silence to CryoNet (1)
- FD-- 03-- Good concluding commentary misses bylaw and polls (1)
- FRED-- 01-- Waiting to hear more from Fred on this. (1)
- GATEKEEPERS-- 01-- Keith Henson's view tended to avoid the original bylaw (1)
- GATEKEEPERS-- 02-- Wowk-VanSickle do NOT respond to Pizer on AU (1)
- GATEKEEPERS-- 05-- Alan Sinclair (1)
- GATEKEEPERS-- Joseph P. Morgan (1)
- GATEKEEPERS-- Steve Bridge-- 01-- My analysis of his comments (1)
- GEORGE-- 00-- takes it too far-- (1)
- KEITH HENSON-- 01-- Henson didn't know about original bylaw (1)
- KEITH HENSON-- 02-- Incidents have nothing to do with original bylaw (1)
- KEITH HENSON-- 03-- KH defends self-electing process based on DoraKent crisis (1)
- KEITH HENSON-- 04-- More history confusing. (1)
- LEADERSHIP-- 01-- Dave denies leadership (1)
- MAXIM-- 01-- Self Electing Boards-- (1)
- MERKLE-- vs. Pizer (1)
- NARRATIVE-- 10-- Silence (1)
- NEW STRATEGY-- 01-- I'll be containing my views (1)
- PETITION-- 00-- ReformAlcor guest book hidden (1)
- POLL-- Alcor-- Alcor bylawy discovery reaction (1)
- POLL-- Alcor-- Do you regard DPizer as leader of Alcor democracy push? (1)
- POLL-- Alcor-- Is Alcor board doing a good job? (1)
- POLL-- Alcor-- Should Alcor change their board election method to include membership votes? (1)
- POLL-- Shannon-- Alcor members vs. Alcor board should vote for board (1)
- POLL-- triper-- term limits (1)
- POLL-- Tripper-- Do you agree with Alcor's goals (1)
- PRIVATE EMAIL GROUP-- 01-- I asked to be deleted from the group (1)
- QUESTIONS by DAVE-- answers by Philossifur (1)
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 01-- Dave lists more than just the democracy debate (1)
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 02-- Members may already have right to vote (1)
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- 03-- Legalities of changing Alcor's board (1)
- REFORM ALCOR.org-- Dave Pizer's forum about democracy at Alcor (1)
- Saul Kent-- buying Alcor? (1)
- SILENCE-- 01-- Contined silence make internet obsolete (1)
- SILENCE-- 02-- Readers don't post (1)
- SILENCE-- 03-- CryoNet under-utilized (1)
- STEVE BRIDGE-- 00-- Intense research on the matter of self-electing boards (1)
- SURVEY-- Shannon Vyff's Poll-- 3 to 1 favor democracy (1)
- takes the wrong route (1)
- TANYA-- 00-- TANYA-- 00-- elect advisors (1)
- TANYA-- vs. Dave's responses (1)
- test (1)
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 01-- blog (1)
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 02-- Back to the real issue post on CF (1)
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY-- 03-- Alcor mysteries vs. bylaw (1)
- TRIPPER MCCARTHY--04-- alternate system ignores bylaw (1)
- VOTE OF CONFIDENCE-- 01-- Cold filter thread examines "how to" (1)
- WEBSITE-- ReformAlcor.org-- 01-- New site announced. (1)
No comments:
Post a Comment